Set-Up

-Bonks bakes the cookies

-Bonks ask Steven to help her with the cookies

-But don't have enough, say, milk

-MonoWither shows up and gives them some. They don't wanna use it but have no choice, so they dump it in anyway.

-After the first batch is done, half of them with normal milk, half with the milk MW gave them.

-Steven decides to try a despair induced milk cookie, getting the Desperation effect or something.

-They go grab some more baking paper in the supply closet, where they find a bottle of MonoWither Poison 2, an Ender Pearl and Rotten Flesh. 

-Zombie flesh and ender pearls + Poison, gloves in Janitor Closet (WHY ARE ENDER PEARLS IN A JANITOR CLOSET)

-Steven secretly takes them, dropping the Flesh behind a nearby plant pot or something.

-They go back to baking cookies.

*Small issue: I went to search a few cookies and they don't require milk (I didn't check a lot so there may be some that uses milk-) In Minecraft, the recipe of a cookie is cocoa beans and wheat, no milk

*Steven is already contemplating murdering someone, the despair effect is what pushed him to.

Execution

-Steven debating internally if he should use the poison on the cookies. His desperation wins and he secretly adds some poison to some of the cookies (so not all cookies were poisoned).

-While batch no. 2 cools, Bonks and Steven leave for a while.

-The latter spots Jordan entering the kitchen and taking one of the cookies.

-He refused himself and follows, witnessing Jordan die just one hallway away from where Bodily is stuck.

-He ender pearls back to Bonks just in time for the cookies to cool.

-He removes the rotten flesh before Bonks serves the poisoned cookies, but left a small chunk behind.

-Some of the cookies had been replaced by MonoWither's cookies, made with the despair milk he had given to them earlier. As they serve the cookies, everyone avoids those replaced cookies. Some of them eat poisoned cookies, commenting on their slightly metallic taste, but immediately drink milk so the poison doesn't kill them.

-Everyone notices Bodil and Jordan missing and set off to find them. It doesn't take too long, as the former wheels himself just far enough to find Jordan's body. He screams, alerting Seto and Tyler, who rush over and trigger the alarm. Annie and the others find them a bit afterwards.

-Jordan investigates smell of rotten flesh (but dies instead) cause it smells like a dead body- Strong smell

-He could of went to tell someone about it as to warn that there is a potential killer on the loose.

-Also, don't you need three people to trigger the body discovery announcement? He could of also gone back, as to find others just in case it was a body. (Though it was not-)

-Jordan may be attracted to a cookie like a noteblock

-Tyler shares milk with Seto through the power of Setler

-Or Tyler gave Seto a flower cookie- through squinting

-Jason noticed Bodil acting weird and confronted him, pressurised him until Bodil told him his FA

- For Bodil, we might as well go with 'Being pushed by the same person for more than 5 minutes'. If this comes to play, he could be pushed by, say, Jason, towards his room, but since the 5 minute timer is almost out, he quickly tells Jason to stop and "he'll get there on his own". But he can't, so he's stuck outside his room, which just happens to be close to the supply closet. He can testify that he never saw Bonks go to the supply closet when she's accused of poisoning the cookies.

*10 minutes for cookies to cool

Investigation

-BODIL CAN SCREAM (Maybe Bodil witnessed Jordan die)

-Jordan has been found a bit away from wherever they eat the cookies, but still in the hallway, possibly past his room

-The group has been split into two: One with the body, one checking other places (Bodil, Jason and Annie group up and search because irony)

-Tyler couldn't see the cookie.

-He almost tripped on it.

-Bonks and Steven give their alibis, Bonks also tells of MW giving them milk

-Someone decides to try a Despair Cookie, is quickly cured with regular milk or by MW not wanting the Show Trial to be messed up, Seto uses the cookie as evidence

-Bodil voices the weird smell coming from the flower pot and the sudden rust on his wheelchair

-Whatever rusted Bodil's wheelchair is found in the kitchen trashcan, along with some fine blue/indigo powder

-Someone voices their bewilderment at the sudden absence of Rotten Flesh and Ender Pearl in the supply closet

-Seto finds the small chuck of rotten flesh left behind and uses it as a clue in the Show Trial

*Despair disease on Steven is lifted. The question is whether he can remember the sin he has committed.

Trial

-Seto, being smart, says that they should start by figuring out the cause of death. Some people argue a bit, but soon they agree

-Discolouration of skin to make it look like he choked, causing them to be slightly confused as to if the one who make the cookies (Bonks) or Jordan would be counted as the murderer

-Someone says that instead of just thinking about one possible cause of death, they should instead think of other ways

-The death seemed like a suicide as cookies are not conventionally weapons. People suspect Jordan drank the poison.

-Seto discovers effects of poison

-Seto has to prove the possibility of a murder and (Jason accuses Bonks) Bonks is now main suspect

-There is the possibility of confusing aliasas, because the kitchen is a general place and anyone could've come in while Bonks was baking. They might only have Bonks to confirm it, but seeming as she is the main suspect, she probably won't be trusted.

-Also, everyone is gonna blame MW cause he placed some cookies too xD

-They can't take the blame away from her unless.. If Bonks have an alibi between the start of the cooling and end of the cooling phase, she would be proven innocent. 

-Alibi: Maybe she was hanging out with someone. Or went to her room and some random person who likes to stay around the rooms noticed she didn't go out. Or the hallway thing? (-Bodil would probably just stay around the rooms. He has trouble moving the wheelchair, and not always will someone be there to help- Did not see Bonks go to supply closet and did not see Steven as he went earlier)

-"Bodil is Bonk's accomplice!" :O YOU EVIL CINNAMON ROLL

-Maybe one needs to wear gloves while handling the poison... Gloves that Bonks' hands might not fit...

2nd Scenario

-They soon come to the conclusion that the poison was found in the supply (or was it janitor's?) Closet

-Jason then accuses Bonks. ( he wouldn't be super aggressive about it, just shocked and horrified that Bonks would do such a thing) Some people agree.

-Bonks refuses that she is the murderer, yet the others start to list/show evidence as to why she could of done it.

-Bodil, who had been by the closet most of the day, states that he had never saw Bonks

-Bodil gets accused of being an accomplice, in which he denies, panicking

-People list evidence of that accusation, such as the fact that was why he said that he didn't see Bonks

-Bonks says that she couldn't of done it, for she was making the cookies most of the day.

-Still accuses her, she could of poisoned the cookies as she was making them

-//Bonks gets away from being suspected. Need more help//

-Bodil suggests the fact that Jordan could of poisoned himself with the cookie

(The two can probably be combined)

-Misconception: Jordan dies by the bangle

-Maybe they found out it was hard to trigger which lowers the possibility of it being the thing that killed him. Unlikely but possible.

-Perhaps Steven lets slip a fact about the cookies or something that only Bonks should have known? Or, if he used gloves, perhaps they could be linked to him somehow (However, if Steven does not retain the memory, this would not be possible)

*Smell of rotten flesh sticks for about a few days to 1 week after removal

*Bonks may have heard the teleporting sound

Execution-

-Execution Music:

-Steven's execution is him getting attacked by each mob he has encountered beforehand (ie. getting blown up by creepers, zombie hordes, ghasts, wolf pack attack, etc.). There is one mob everyone's eyes are drawn to. It is a slime, looking very depressed.

Post Trial

-Jerry is given to Jason to take care 

Things we need to figure out

-exact events of the day (before death)

-a THOROUGH chart of who eats what cookies and when

-dialogue

-who discovers what