Apple Jack met Twilight in front of SugarCube Corner that day.

"There you are Twi." Apple Jack said when Twilight approached the bakery.

"Sorry, Spike needed me" Twilight looked at SugarCube Corner.

"Alrighty let's get started." Apple Jack walked in with Twilight following her. Mr. Cake and Mrs. Cake were there.

"Hello girls" Mrs. Cake smiled.

"Hi, we have something we need to ask." Twilight looked around as she talked.

"Do you have any uh attics, basements or hidden doors here?" Apple Jack cut Twilight off.

"Not that we know of..." Mr. Cake told them.

Mrs. Cake nodded but said, "Feel free to look around if you'd like to." Twilight and Apple Jack walked behind the counter. Apple Jack knelt down to look for any hidden doors. Twilight saw a shelf filled with cupcakes, it was big enough to hide a door.

"Apple Jack, come help me movie this." Twilight looked over at AJ. AJ stood up and walked over.

"I'll get one side.." Twilight told AJ. Both girls moved the shelf. A door stood tall.

"You sure you want to so this?" Apple Jack looked at Twilight and she nodded. Apple Jack put her hand on the door knob and turned it, revealing a long staircase. Twilight ran down the stairs.

"Twi!" AJ ran after her. There was another door.

"It's locked." Twilight stated.

"No it ain't." Apple Jack took out an old key. Twilight looked surprised.

"Where did you get this!?" Twilight looked at the key.

"I found it while searching the floor up there." Apple Jack chuckled and opened the door. They smelt something terrible. Twilight walked around a dark room. The door locked. Twilight backed up into another pony.

"Apple Jack...is that you? Did you find anything?"

Twilight whispered.

"Twilight you're here!" A familiar cheerful voice giggled.

"P-Pinkie." Twilight gulped.

"Duh! You're just in time for our game!" Pinkie giggled again.

"Game??? Where's Apple Jack!?" Twilight shouted.

"We've already started!" A dim light was turned on and Twilight screamed. Blood was everywhere, knives and other tools were scattered on a metal table, a banner was strung across a wall, pony parts were on the wall and on tables, and a metal table with metal restraints. Apple Jack was on the table.

"I'm sorry Twilight, you two have seen to much." Pinkie sighed.

"P-Pinkie no! We won't tell anyone we promise!"

Twilight looked Apple Jack who was unconscious.

"That's what they all say." Pinkie told her in a song song voice. Apple Jack was waking up.

"Now you two...it's a game!...Smile for me?"

Pinkie giggled.