After moving to a new town, you also start going to a new school. The 'bad boy' seems to have an eye for you, but you don't want anything to do with him. Eventually, you find out why he has an eye for you.

He's the towns serial killer and targets girls/boys who look like you.

(Just to preface this, when I find these or make them, I always copy them or put down as second person because that way you can interpret the character how you want! Just to clear that up)