The whole clan heard Appledusk run toward the river and surrounded him."Well looks like we caught a fish far from the river!"Then Mapleshade and Beetail emerged from the undergrowth behind Oakstar and said:

"What is Appledusk doing here?"Mapleshade what?.....You betrayed me you where my mate!"Appledusk screeched then realized that her whole clan had heard.

Instead of being angry Mapleshade and her clanmates laughed"Oh Appledusk you say that I cheated on you well what are you doing with Reedshine as your mate?"

Appledusk looked surprised."Yes, I was there when you asked her and after the birth of my kits, I asked Beetail to be my mate, for I knew that he would be loyal to me!"

Then Appledusk looked at the ground and whispered."Y....You saw that and you betrayed me and those kits are our kits, not just yours."Oh, Appledusk they are my kits for I gave birth to them and raised them to be Thunderclan, now get lost or I will rip your fur off!"

Mapleshade screeched at him, and Appledusk ran until he reached the river and swam to Riverclans side and yelled:

"This is not over Mapleshade you will die at my paws."At these words, Mapleshade laughed for she knew that his death would be at her paws, Starclan had it before her she knew it.For it was her destiny.