I haven't read any books with Alderpaw in them so I don't really have an opinion on that.

Eliminated: Alderpaw

~ Squirrelflight
~ Jayfeather
~ Hollyleaf
~ Sparkpaw
~ Hollytuft
~ Sorrelstripe
~ Fernsong

This poll is of Firestar's Descendants. Of the cats listed above, comment your LEAST favorite. Cat with the most votes is out.