how could anyone ever hate her?!

Okay, for anyone who doesn't like her, I'm going to explain to you.

first of all, hollypaw was very nice and smart and always was there for her littermates. and she, along with Lionpaw said jaypaw should have been a warrior. And despite everything she's been threw, she holds together, if I found out my father was windclan, I'd explode.

Also, as Hollyleaf decided she now wanted to be a warrior, which is completely fine, because spottedleaf went to a med cat after being a warrior, so did leafpool and lots of cats, and she was a bit unsure about being a medicine cat at the start anyways, so don't give her a hard time about it.

because jaypaw and Lionpaw went on about how she'd smell bad, and never coulnt or fight, and had to clean disgusting wounds, obviously she'd be a bit nervous, so I can't blame her for switching. her new mentor, brackenfur, somewhat made her feel as if she wasn't trying hard enough, and she only wanted her clan to be strong!

when ashfur took them into that fire, she was heart broken when the secret came out, which of course snapped her, you guys don't get how bad it is for there parents to not be a normal warrior. Knowing that, sense you love the warrioirs code so much.. And you yourself being alive are against it.

now, it was confirmed, hollyleaf didn't mean to kill ashfur, he jumped at her, she shoved him back for self defence with her claws, he fell into the river and drowned, hollyleaf couldn't help him

When the secret came out people, it broke.her.heart. To learn she wasn't even suppost to be born and is against the warrior code herself when that's all she cared about! She was even more upset when jayfeather told her SHE ruined everything. I know she told them all so you say he died for nothing,-ashfur- but she regretted him dying and told the clans because now she couldn't avoid it anyways.

Then later learning her littermates would save the clan, she was upset and found it hard to understand why dovewing was the third, not her, how cruel is star clan, make all her littermates important cats to save everyone, but leave out there sister for Pete sake!

starclan has been wrong before, so dovewing shouldn't have been the third, they have been wrong before, making tigerstar leader! come. On. Dovewing doesn't deserve that third place. At all.

Frig.

Sorry.