Please Correct Me If Any Info. Is Wrong :-):-D:-P:-!

Hey! Did you see the moon recently? Cause where I'm at its RED! I think its cause of mars eclipse.... DID SOL KNOW ABOUT THIS?...
I'm saying this on Wednesday night, so look out your window to see a red moon!

P.s. positive side
n.s. Negative side
SPOILERS
SPOILERS
SPOILERS
There, I warned you.

So, here's how this goes...
I'm going to write names down, and a few arguments why not or why they should be deputy/leader and under whose leadership.

Bramblestar

Squirrelflight

N. S.
One of the Erin's said she might die before Bramblestar.
She's not very liked after the Ash-Bramble thing.
She's a bit hotheaded.

P. S.
she's warming up to her position.
she knows how to run things
She's experienced ↓
She has a mothers love now
It runs in her blood.
good mentor.

Lionblaze

N. S.
He's pretty young, a bit inexperienced
he's not very liked 'cause "he's a marry-sue" and he's gotta be so perfect.
He's only got one apprentice.
A bit hotheaded when it comes to his family.
They killed Lionheart off because their already was a Lionstar of ThunderClan, so possibly not unless we beg!

P. S.
He's not old like Whitestorm was.
he's kinda smart because all the stuff he's gone through. Experienced.
he's had an apprentice.
He's used to a lot of responsibility.
He understands the order of things.
He's strong, not frail.
He knows how to use his claws right.
It runs in his blood.
He's a father.
Good mentor. (Smart)
he's close to StarClan.
his brother could aid him through his leadership.

Ashfur

N.S.
He's dead. Might be a SMALL problem....
He had about five popular cats that absolutely hated him.
He went crazy.
people (fans) hate him for trying to kill J-H-L.
Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw disliked him.
Bramblestar might not like him being his deputy....
He's not very understanding.
He loved to much.

P. S.
He's experienced.
Had I think two apprentices. (Please correct me)
The rest of the clan liked him.
Some hints were made in Sunset.
He's young and popular.
Smart, experienced, wise.
He's defiantly got a mothers love.
He's never been to the Dark Forest(?)

Squirrelstar/Bramblestar
Sparkpaw/Alderpaw
P. S.
If they're anything like their parents, they're meant to be a leader.
Sparkpaw has an awesome name.
They'll be good cats, no doubt.
I think so.
It's in their genes.
Both their parents are very trusted.
it sounds like they have important roles later on.

N. S.
We have no clue about them.
They don't have the best mentors.
They had two siblings die, they may be grieving still or go all crazy like Tallstar did for revenge.
They're probably not the smartest .
May be battle hungry.
Some cat from the dark forest that survived might haunt them.

Bramblestar
Lilyheart

N. S.
No apprentice(?) I though she did... Who?
Not super strong physically.
Probably has a weak spot, but all cats do.
Might have a mental breakdown because her family almost all disappeared. (Died)
Might go through a Bluestar faze.
I know, these aren't entirely true or good reasons, but I needed something.

P. S.
She's mentally strong.
Experienced.
Has a kind heart.
Understanding.
Respects all ranks, kits to elders.
She has authority and knows how to get it.
She's got kits to fight for.

Firestar (he would be to old by now)
Brackenfur

N. S.
A bit older than the deputies normally.
He isn't the most popular among fans.
He isn't a main character. *spits*

P. S.
he's mentally and physically strong.
Experienced.
Has a kind heart.
Understanding.
His family and mentor and apprentices are respected, giving him a good reputation.
Respects all ranks, kits to elders.
He has authority and knows how to get it.
He's very trusted.
No one dislikes him.
He was also hinted at in Sunset.
He's been through a lot, giving him strength to fight for something(his last kin lilyheart)
He's awesome.
He'll defiantly get his lives from family.
Sorreltail Ferncloud Seedpaw Firestar Feathertail Cinderpelt My cat that ran away. Or a an apprentice.
He's popular but not the center of attention.
Did I mention, he's awesome?

Please give suggestions and your arguments in the comments!
I've started Oncestar's nine lives!