I liked her...When she was a kit! I'm not really glad she got hit by a car, but she had to. Because, If she hadn't been hit by a car, Firestar might (probably 10% chance) be her mate, And Squirrelflight and Leafpool wouldn't have been born. And if they hadn't been born, then Jayfeather, Lionblaze and Hollyleaf wouldn't be born, and without them, there would be no clans and Tigerstar would've taken over!