I hate him in everyway. He tried to kíll Oakheart. He made Tigerstar Bloodthirsty. Because if him, Tiny became Scourge. And for the record, Thisleclaw was training in the Dark Forest as an apprentice and went there when he died. He was never chased out! Bluestar never did anything. And remember? Thisleclaw tried to take Bluefur away from Whitekit.